Sen. Mike Younger blasts his chamber for ignoring the governor’s name for a particular session about redistricting, on Group Day, held on Tuesday, Nov. 18, 2025. (Photograph by Leslie Bonilla Muñiz/Indiana Capital Chronicle)
For many years, Hoosier governors and lawmakers have sparred over what may be completed throughout a particular legislative session. However state leaders at the moment are confronting a special dilemma — can the Common Meeting legally ignore a governor’s demand to convene?
Indiana’s debate reached a brand new breaking level Tuesday when the Senate chamber voted to adjourn till Jan. 5, rebutting Gov. Mike Braun’s name for a particular session on redistricting.
The Senate’s determination to easily not present up seems to be unprecedented in state historical past.
Republican Sen. Mike Younger, who helps redistricting, mentioned Tuesday that lawmakers are already, by definition, in a particular session and due to this fact can’t ignore it.
“The governor has the facility to name us right into a particular session, which he’s completed,” Younger mentioned. “However we’ve got a proper as a physique to set a special schedule. … We may have been in and adjourned, sine die, however we selected to not do it. It is a slap within the face of the governor of the state of Indiana.”
He informed the Indiana Capital Chronicle that the legislature should not less than gavel out and in of the particular session — even when redistricting issues are left untouched.
“We first need to go in,” Younger mentioned. “I’m not saying we’ve got to do any work. I’m simply saying they’re not following the principles of the Structure.”
However Senate President Professional Tem Rodric Bray, who leads the chamber, informed reporters the alternative.
“It doesn’t seem like an issue that we will decide as as to whether we are available in or not,” Bray mentioned, citing inner authorized recommendation to the Senate.
Republican Home Speaker Todd Huston supplied solely a short response Tuesday when requested whether or not he believes the legislature can ignore the particular session name totally.
Home Speaker Todd Huston talks to reporters on Group Day, held on Tuesday, Nov. 18, 2025. (Leslie Bonilla Muñiz/Indiana Capital Chronicle)
“We’ll see if that’s even crucial,” Huston mentioned.
Going through mounting resistance from his personal get together, Braun mentioned he’s now in search of methods to “compel” the Senate to behave. The governor’s workplace had no additional particulars on what authority he believes he can use. He did radio and tv interviews Wednesday however didn’t embody print reporters.
The legislature beforehand deliberate to satisfy Dec. 1 to take up President Donald Trump’s want for Republican-led states to attract extra GOP-friendly U.S. Home districts forward of the 2026 midterm elections.
Indiana’s Senate Republican management has maintained the caucus lacks sufficient help to move mid-cycle congressional maps. GOP senators have been cut up 19-19 in a vote to adjourn till January. It handed with Democrat help.
‘I don’t see the place the legislature can ignore that’
Over the final century, governors of each events have relied on particular periods to resolve deadlocks, rewrite tax codes and full budgets. Whereas government and legislative leaders have clashed, at occasions, over the content material and size of particular periods, historic information reviewed by the Capital Chronicle confirmed no examples of the Common Meeting merely refusing to convene in any respect.
In 1865, then-Gov. Oliver Morton known as a particular session to deal with Civil Battle–period monetary emergencies and reorganize state establishments. In 1919, Gov. James Goodrich summoned lawmakers so Indiana may ratify the nineteenth Modification.
In 2002 and once more in 2018, governors convened particular periods to sort out unfinished payments and full price range work. And in 2022, former Gov. Eric Holcomb known as lawmakers again for a particular session that in the end produced the state’s near-total abortion ban.
The Indiana Structure gives that “if, within the opinion of the Governor, the general public welfare shall require it, he might, at any time by proclamation, name a particular session.”
Indiana Senate President Professional Tempore Rodric Bray mingles at an occasion on the Indiana Statehouse on Tuesday, Nov. 18, 2025. (Photograph by Leslie Bonilla Muñiz/Indiana Capital Chronicle)
However the Structure additionally grants every chamber authority to “decide its guidelines of continuing, and sit upon its personal adjournment.” It doesn’t say what occurs if lawmakers merely don’t convene.
Who controls the session’s size, agenda and existence as soon as known as has been debated since Indiana’s first constitutional conference in 1816 and once more in 1850.
It resurfaced most lately in a 2022 Indiana Supreme Court docket case involving Holcomb.
In that case, the excessive court docket justices struck down a statute — Home Enrolled Act 1123 — that will have allowed the Legislative Council to name the total legislature into particular session. The justices held that the governor alone has that authority — however notably didn’t resolve whether or not the legislature is legally required to satisfy as soon as the governor calls them in.
The 2022 ruling additionally traced how delegates in 1850 explicitly rejected proposals to permit the legislature to name itself into session — proof which the justices mentioned mirrored a deliberate option to vest that energy solely within the governor.
The opinion additional famous that whereas governors traditionally initiated particular periods, “the Common Meeting retained authority over the conduct and period of such periods.”
Indiana Code at the moment caps particular periods at not more than 30 session days and not more than 40 calendar days following the primary day of the governor’s desired session calendar.”
Former Home Speaker Brian Bosma, who served in additional than half a dozen particular periods throughout his tenure, mentioned his studying of the Indiana Structure is that lawmakers are required to convene, even when just for minutes.
Former Indiana Home Speaker Brian Bosma (Photograph from Ballotpedia)
“My private view, my learn of the Structure and statutes as a lawyer, is that the governor has each proper to name us as a result of it’s a singular proper to name a particular session. And I don’t see the place the legislature can ignore that,” Bosma mentioned. “However what I’m assured the legislature may do is are available in on the primary day and adjourn.”
He added that lawmakers may “adjourn after two minutes,” taking attendance, saying the pledge, and ending the session in the event that they select.
“It appears to me that the legislature is compelled to be there,” Bosma continued, “but it surely may adjourn.”
The previous Home speaker pointed to a notable gathering in 1991, when Senate Republicans abruptly adjourned the primary particular session throughout a price range deadlock — and “nobody questioned (then-Senate President Professional Tem Bob Garton’s) authority to take action.”
Might Braun drive lawmakers to look?
Inside legislative insurance policies may assist compel some senators — however provided that sufficient present up within the chamber first.
Senate guidelines, for instance, permit 25 members to “compel the attendance of absent Senators.” There are 40 Republican senators at the moment in workplace.
If not less than 25 senators appeared — together with Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith, who presides over the Senate as its constitutional president — they may order absent senators to return, situation calls of the Senate, or adjourn.
However, crucially, these powers apply solely after the Senate gavels into session. If the chamber by no means convenes, none of these enforcement mechanisms may be activated.
Indiana has some precedent for large-scale absences, although. In 2011, Democrats fled the state throughout a weeks-long walkout over “right-to-work” laws.
Bosma mentioned “there was dialogue up to now” of the governor “dispatching the state police to gather folks up and produce them in” — together with in 2011. However whereas “it’s been threatened, it’s by no means occurred.”
Within the wake of that walkout, Indiana enacted “anti-bolting” legal guidelines that permit the Home and Senate to superb members who deliberately refuse to attend and stop a quorum. These penalties can attain $1,000 per day. However these statutes apply solely when the chamber is already in session — that means they supply no mechanism for implementing attendance at a particular session lawmakers by no means convene.
Bosma emphasised that then-Gov. Mitch Daniels declined to ship state police to retrieve the absent lawmakers, nonetheless, and famous that such a transfer at this time may very well be politically explosive.
“Definitely, it wouldn’t be completed, I might assume, (by) a Republican governor to Republican legislators,” he mentioned. “However we’ll see the way it performs out.”
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX