April 17, 2025
Choose Joe Brown analyzes Karmelo Anthony case so far and offers his professional opinion.
Choose Joe Brown is weighing in on the case of Karmelo Anthony, a 17-year-old who was arrested for homicide.
The previous tv decide sat down with YouTube creator TheRealDana to debate the circumstances surrounding Anthony’s arrest and the authorized implications of the case.
In line with Brown, if Anthony have been assaulted within the fee of a theft, then he can be thought-about a sufferer.
“He’s not a perpetrator,” Brown mentioned within the interview. “He’s a sufferer of a theft. You possibly can’t maintain him accountable for the conduct of anyone else.”
Choose Brown additionally criticized the bond set for Anthony, arguing it was unjust. He defined that bail is just not supposed to replicate public opinion or punishment, however moderately exists solely to make sure a defendant’s return to court docket.
“If a defendant has no prior document, and there’s no flight threat, then the legislation says there needs to be an affordable bond set,” Brown mentioned. “That younger man needs to be awaiting trial outdoors of jail.”
Anthony was initially given a $1 million bond. Supporters have since rallied to assist his household elevate funds. His subsequent court docket date has not been introduced but.
On April 2, 2025, 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony was arrested and charged with first-degree homicide after allegedly fatally stabbing fellow scholar Austin Metcalf throughout a highschool observe meet at Kuykendall Stadium in Frisco, Texas. In line with witness accounts and police reviews, the altercation started when Metcalf requested Anthony to maneuver from an space designated for Metcalf’s staff. The state of affairs escalated, and Anthony allegedly stabbed Metcalf as soon as within the chest. Metcalf died on the scene, reportedly within the arms of his twin brother.
Anthony claimed he acted in self-defense, stating that Metcalf had grabbed him throughout the dispute. He was initially held on a $1 million bond, which was later decreased to $250,000. Following the bond discount, Anthony was launched on home arrest, topic to circumstances that included carrying an ankle monitor and acquiring judicial permission earlier than leaving residence.
The case has garnered vital public consideration, and fundraisers have been established for each households. Supporters of Anthony have raised over $431,000 for his authorized protection, whereas a separate fundraiser in reminiscence of Metcalf has collected over $500,000.
Because the investigation continues, the case shall be introduced to a grand jury for consideration. As a consequence of Anthony’s age, he isn’t eligible for the dying penalty or life with out parole, in accordance with a 2005 Supreme Court docket ruling.
RELATED CONTENT: Karmelo Anthony’s Lawyer Desires $1M Bond Lowered, Arguing Self-Protection In Austin Metcalf Homicide Case