El Salvador President Nayib Bukele framed his provide to accommodate “harmful American criminals” and “criminals from any nation” as a win-win for all.
The charge for transferring detainees to a newly constructed Salvadoran mega-prison “can be comparatively low” for the U.S. however sufficient to make El Salvador’s “whole jail system sustainable,” Bukele wrote in a submit on the social media platform X dated Feb. 3, 2025.
What was left unsaid is that the people can be knowingly positioned into a jail system through which a spread of sources have reported widespread human rights abuses by the hands of state forces.
A primary switch of U.S. deportees from Venezuela has now arrived into that system. On March 16, the U.S. authorities flew round 250 deportees to El Salvador regardless of a choose’s order quickly blocking the transfer. Bukele later posted a video on-line exhibiting the deportees arriving in El Salvador with their fingers and toes shackled and forcibly bent over by armed guards.
As consultants who’ve researched human rights and jail circumstances in El Salvador, we have now documented an alarming democratic decline amid Bukele’s makes an attempt to conceal ongoing violence each in prisons and all through the nation.
We’ve additionally heard firsthand of the human rights abuses that deportees and Salvadorans alike say they’ve suffered whereas incarcerated in El Salvador, and we have now labored on tons of of asylum circumstances as knowledgeable witnesses, testifying in U.S. immigration court docket in regards to the nature and scope of human rights abuses within the nation. We’re deeply involved each over the circumstances into which deportees are arriving and as to what the U.S. administration’s resolution indicators about its commitments to worldwide human rights requirements.
Eroding democratic norms
Bukele has led El Salvador since 2019, successful the presidency by vowing to crack down on the crime and corruption that had plagued the nation. However he has additionally circumvented democratic norms – for instance, by rewriting the structure in order that he might be reelected in 2024.
For the previous three years, Bukele has ruled with few checks and balances beneath a self-imposed “state of exception.” This emergency standing has allowed Bukele to droop many rights as he wages what he calls a “struggle on gangs.”
The crackdown manifests in mass arbitrary arrests of anybody who suits stereotypical demographic traits of gang members, like having tattoos, a previous prison document and even simply “wanting nervous.”
Because of the continuing mass arrests, El Salvador now has the highest incarceration price on the planet. The proportion of its inhabitants that El Salvador incarcerates is greater than triple that of the U.S. and double that of the following nearest nation, Cuba.
Most secure nation in Latin America?
Bukele’s tough-on-gangs persona has earned him widespread reputation at residence and overseas – he has fostered a right away friendship with the brand new U.S. administration specifically.
However sustaining this reputation has concerned, it’s broadly alleged, manipulating crime statistics, attacking journalists who criticize him and denying involvement in a broadly documented secret gang pact that unraveled simply earlier than the beginning of the state of exception.
Bukele and pro-government Salvadoran media insist that the crackdown on gangs has reworked El Salvador into the most secure nation in Latin America.
However on the bottom, Salvadorans have described how police, navy personnel and Mexican cartels have taken over the exploitative practices beforehand carried out by gangs like MS-13 and Barrio 18. One Salvadoran girl whose son died in jail just some days after he was arbitrarily detained advised a reporter from Al Jazeera: “One is all the time afraid. Earlier than it was concern of the gangs, now it’s additionally the safety forces who take harmless individuals.”
Torture as state coverage
Bukele’s crackdown on gangs has come at an enormous price to human rights – and nowhere is that this seen greater than in El Salvador’s jail system.
Bukele has ordered a communication blackout between incarcerated individuals and their family members. This implies no visits, no letters and no cellphone calls.
Such lack of contact makes it almost not possible for individuals to find out the well-being of their incarcerated members of the family, lots of whom are dad and mom with younger youngsters now cared for by prolonged household.
Regardless of the blackout, students, worldwide and nationwide rights’ teams and investigative journalists have been in a position to construct up an image of circumstances inside El Salvador’s prisons by way of interviews with victims and their members of the family, medical data and forensic evaluation of circumstances of jail deaths. What they describe is a hellscape.
Incarcerated Salvadorans are packed into grossly overcrowded cells, overwhelmed frequently by jail personnel and denied medicines even when they’re obtainable. Inmates are incessantly subjected to punishments together with meals deprivation and electrical shocks. Certainly, a U.S. State Division’s 2023 nation report on El Salvador famous the “harsh and life-threatening jail circumstances.”
The human rights group Cristosal estimates that tons of have died from malnutrition, blunt drive trauma, strangulation and lack of lifesaving medical remedy.
Usually, their our bodies are buried by authorities employees in mass graves with out notifying households.
Though El Salvador is a signatory to the United Nations’ Conference Towards Torture, Amnesty Worldwide concluded after a number of missions to the nation and interviews with victims and their households that there’s “systemic use of torture” in Salvadoran prisons.
Likewise, a case-by-case examine by Cristosal, which included forensic evaluation of exhumed our bodies of people that died in jail, decided in 2024 that “torture has develop into a state coverage.”
‘Prone to irreparable hurt’
What makes this all of the extra worrying is the size of potential abuse.
El Salvador now homes a jail inhabitants of round 110,000 – greater than 3 times the quantity of inmates earlier than the state of exception started.
To extend the nation’s capability for ongoing mass incarceration, Bukele constructed and opened the Terrorism Confinement Middle mega-prison in 2023. An evaluation of the middle utilizing satellite tv for pc footage confirmed that if the jail had been to succeed in its full supposed capability of 40,000, every prisoner would have lower than 2 toes of house of their cells.
It’s to this jail that deportees from the U.S. have been taken.
President Donald Trump invoked the 1798 Alien Enemies Act in transferring the detainees. The wartime act has been invoked solely 3 times, together with to justify Japanese internment throughout World Warfare II.
There are critical considerations over each the method and the legality of transferring U.S. prisoners to a nation that has not protected the human rights of its detained inhabitants.
Whereas Trump mentioned the deportees had been members of the gangs Tren de Aragua and MS-13, the incarcerated people didn’t obtain a listening to to contest allegations of their gang membership, eliciting questions as to the viability of that declare.
Furthermore, the settlement by way of which the Trump administration is in search of to transferring migrants detained within the U.S. to El Salvador faces scrutiny beneath worldwide legislation, given what is understood in regards to the nation’s jail circumstances.
Worldwide human rights is ruled by legal guidelines that prohibit nations from transferring individuals into hurt’s approach, be it returning overseas nationals to nations the place “there are substantial grounds for believing that the particular person can be susceptible to irreparable hurt,” or transferring detainees to jurisdictions through which they’re susceptible to being tortured or merciless, inhuman or degrading remedy.
The efforts of human rights organizations, journalists and students to doc jail circumstances level to an unequivocal conclusion: El Salvador doesn’t meet the phrases obligatory to guard the human rights of deported and incarcerated migrants.
On the contrary, the federal government of El Salvador has repeatedly been accused by rights teams of committing crimes towards humanity, together with towards its jail inhabitants.
Mneesha Gellman, Affiliate Professor of Political Science, Emerson Faculty and Sarah C. Bishop, Professor, Baruch Faculty, CUNY
This text is republished from The Dialog beneath a Inventive Commons license. Learn the authentic article.
SEE ALSO:
Division Of Training Is Being Dismantled By Trump Government Order