February 8, 2025
Englemayer, acknowledged that anybody who’s prohibited from getting access to the delicate knowledge retroactive to Jan. 20 should instantly destroy all copies of any materials downloaded from Treasury Division programs
On Feb. 8, U.S. District Choose Paul A. Engelmayer issued a preliminary injunction after 19 Democratic attorneys common sued Donald Trump to cease Elon Musk’s Division of Authorities Effectivity (DOGE) from accessing Treasury Division information which have delicate taxpayer info, comparable to Social Safety and checking account numbers of thousands and thousands of Individuals.
In response to Time Journal, the case, which was filed in New York Metropolis, alleged that the Trump Administration’s resolution to offer Musk and his DOGE crew entry to the Treasury Division’s central fee system was a violation of federal regulation.
In his ruling, Englemayer, an appointee of President Barack Obama, acknowledged that anybody who’s prohibited from getting access to the delicate knowledge retroactive to Jan. 20, should instantly destroy all copies of any materials downloaded from Treasury Division programs.
New York Legal professional Common Letitia James, whose workplace filed the lawsuit in opposition to Trump, stated that Musk and DOGE’s entry to delicate info raises safety points and a chance for unlawful freezes of federal funds.
“This unelected group, led by the world’s richest man, is just not approved to have this info, they usually explicitly sought this unauthorized entry to illegally block funds that thousands and thousands of Individuals depend on, funds for well being care, youngster care and different important applications,” James stated by way of a video message launched by her workplace Feb. 7.
In a press launch despatched to BLACK ENTERPRISE by James’ workplace on Feb. 8, she additionally referred to as consideration to the impact Musk’s seizure of delicate knowledge has had on Individuals throughout the nation.
“From the second Elon Musk and his DOGE workers gained unprecedented entry to our private non-public knowledge, state checking account particulars, and different delicate info, Individuals throughout the nation have been horrified. Over the previous week, my workplace has heard from greater than a thousand New Yorkers who had been afraid they’d lose their privateness and the vital funding their communities depend on due to Musk and DOGE’s interference.”
James continued, “We knew the Trump administration’s selection to offer this entry to unauthorized people was unlawful, and this morning, a federal courtroom agreed. I’ve stated it earlier than, and I’ll say it once more: nobody is above the regulation. Now, Individuals can belief that Musk – the world’s richest man – and his mates won’t have free rein over their private info whereas our lawsuit proceeds.”
In response to the lawsuit, DOGE’s entry to the non-public info of taxpayers is each a violation of federal regulation and america Structure’s doctrine of the separation of powers.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent can be accused of fixing the division’s lengthy standing coverage of defending delicate knowledge to permit Musk and his cronies entry.
“This resolution did not account for authorized obligations to guard such knowledge and ignored the privateness expectations of federal fund recipients,” which incorporates states, veterans, retirees, and taxpayers, the lawsuit states.
In response to a press release from Connecticut Legal professional Common William Tong, “That is the biggest knowledge breach in American historical past. DOGE is an unlawfully constituted band of renegade tech bros combing by way of confidential information, delicate knowledge and significant fee programs. What might go unsuitable?”
The ACLU has additionally stepped as much as problem Musk’s entry to delicate info, as Nathan Freed Wessler, the Deputy Director of the ACLU’s Speech, Privateness, and Know-how Mission indicated in a press launch.
The group referred to as on Congress to do its job and test the chief department’s overreach of energy by way of a letter it despatched to varied Senate and Home finance-related committee members.
“The American folks should know if their non-public monetary, medical, and private information are being illegally accessed, analyzed, or weaponized by Trump’s unaccountable crew of unvetted outsiders. There’s each indication that DOGE has compelled its approach into the federal government’s most tightly protected databases and programs, with out consideration of longstanding privateness safeguards mandated by Congress. We’d like solutions now,” Wessler stated.
RELATED CONTENT: Federal Staff Blocking Musk’s DOGE Workers Might Be Breaking The Regulation, US Prosecutor Says