QuickBooks Payroll is a well-liked pay processing software program due to its full-service payroll, well-rounded options, and quick syncing with the QuickBooks accounting system. Nonetheless, it has restricted HR instruments and could be expensive to make use of, relying on the plan you get. In the event you’re searching for a QuickBooks Payroll different that prices much less, handles international worker funds, or gives extra HR options, listed here are some choices you’ll be able to contemplate.
High QuickBooks Payroll alternate options comparability
These alternate options to QuickBooks Payroll, together with QuickBooks, supply tax reporting and submitting help, automated pay computations, advantages administration, and important instruments to handle worker data.
| Beginning month-to-month worth | Separate contractor plan (monthly) | International payroll instruments | Time monitoring | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QuickBooks Payroll | $50 base price + $6 per worker | $15 for as much as 20 staff + $2 per extra employee | No | Included in increased tiers |
| Gusto | $40 base price + $6 per worker | $35 base price + $6 per employee | Sure | Included in increased tiers |
| OnPay | $40 base price + $6 per worker | No | No | Through integrations |
| Sq. Payroll | $35 base price + $6 per worker | $6 per employee | No | Sure |
| Paychex Flex | Customized | No | No | Paid add-on |
| RUN Powered by ADP | Customized | No | Sure | Paid add-on |
Gusto: Finest general
As a payroll software program, Gusto has most of the identical perks as QuickBooks, equivalent to automated wage and tax computations, wage garnishments, and automatic tax filings. Nonetheless, it has a broader vary of HR options to streamline the worker lifecycle. It might submit jobs, onboard staff, monitor attendance, plan work shifts, and monitor efficiency opinions.
Gusto also can pay worldwide contractors in over 120 international locations. And with its employer of file (EOR) service, Gusto International, it might compliantly rent and pay staff in Australia, Brazil, Canada, Germany, India, Eire, Mexico, the Netherlands, the Philippines, Portugal, the UK, and Spain (as of this writing).
Pricing
QuickBooks Payroll and Gusto supply three plans, however Gusto’s starter tier is barely cheaper. It solely prices $40 plus $6 per worker month-to-month, whereas QuickBooks Payroll’s starter plan is priced at $50 plus $6 per worker month-to-month. Plus, Gusto’s starter tier has extra HR options, equivalent to primary paid day without work (PTO) insurance policies, {custom} supply letter templates, and onboarding checklists.
Listed here are its pricing plans:
- Easy: $40 base price monthly plus $6 per worker monthly.
- Plus: $80 base price monthly plus $12 per worker monthly.
- Premium: $180 base price monthly plus $22 per worker monthly.
It additionally gives a contractor plan in case you solely pay contract staff.
- Contractor solely: $35 base price monthly plus $6 per employee month-to-month.
Whereas Gusto’s contractor plan isn’t as inexpensive as QuickBooks Payroll’s ($15 month-to-month for as much as 20 staff plus $2 per extra employee), Gusto contains new rent reporting in its bundle. This could prevent time, particularly if your online business is situated in California or a state that requires corporations to report newly employed contract staff.
Gusto professionals and cons
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
When to decide on Gusto over QuickBooks Payroll
Gusto is my high QuickBooks Payroll different primarily due to its feature-rich platform. It’s nice in order for you a payroll system that may handle hiring to onboarding duties with ease. QuickBooks doesn’t have an applicant monitoring system (ATS) to watch candidates, and its onboarding options aren’t as intensive. With Gusto, you’ll be able to monitor candidates, create digital welcome playing cards for brand new hires, handle e-mail and software program entry, and run background checks by way of Checkr immediately from its platform.
Relating to payroll taxes and tax filings, each will calculate federal, state, and native taxes, however solely Gusto contains tax cost and submitting help throughout all ranges in its starter tier. With QuickBooks, you could improve to at the least its Premium plan to get automated native tax submitting companies.
Gusto’s functionalities additionally prolong past simply processing US and international payroll. It might assist with state tax registration and gives an R&D tax credit score service that permits you to save as much as $250,000 in payroll taxes every year. So, between options and pricing, I contemplate Gusto the highest different to QuickBooks Payroll for many small companies.
Be taught extra about Gusto
OnPay: Finest worth for cash
What units OnPay other than QuickBooks Payroll and the others on my listing is its flat-rate pricing. You solely get one plan, with all its options and companies included in that bundle. So, you by no means have to fret about whether or not or not a particular performance will value you additional or require a plan improve.
OnPay’s easy pricing additionally provides you loads of bang on your buck. For a month-to-month price of $40 plus $6 per worker, you get full-service payroll, entry to advantages plans, worker self-service instruments, and important HR and crew administration options. As an added perk, OnPay offers white-glove setup and knowledge migration assist to get you began ― at no additional value to you. So, even when OnPay isn’t the most affordable or lacks international payroll companies, it nonetheless gives an excellent steadiness between pricing and options.
Pricing
OnPay has only one plan, with all options included. It prices $40 monthly plus $6 per worker, which is barely cheaper than QuickBooks Payroll’s starter tier ($50 plus $6 per worker monthly). Just like Gusto, OnPay gives extra HR functionalities than QuickBooks.
Nonetheless, OnPay doesn’t have a separate contractor-only plan. It’s important to pay the identical charge as its full-service payroll tier, even in case you solely must course of contractor funds. I like to recommend utilizing Sq. Payroll in order for you a QuickBooks Payroll different that gives a low-cost contractor bundle.
OnPay professionals and cons
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
When to decide on OnPay over QuickBooks Payroll
OnPay made my listing of the highest alternate options to QuickBooks Payroll due to the vary of core HR options that it offers. Along with its HR data system (HRIS) module to handle worker knowledge and paperwork, you get a searchable firm listing and on-line org chart that routinely updates based mostly on adjustments to OnPay’s worker profiles.
I additionally respect its customizable day without work insurance policies, which let you create as much as three accrual guidelines. This allows staff to earn PTO credit at completely different charges relying on varied elements like worker sort, tenure, and work location. Whereas QuickBooks additionally has customizable accrual insurance policies, it isn’t as versatile as OnPay’s.
Additional, creating payroll stories is less complicated with OnPay. You possibly can add or take away a column, drag and drop it to your required place, and use filters to pick gadgets. You possibly can even add considered one of its collapsible “good column” teams, which comprise a number of columns of associated knowledge, equivalent to work hours and employer taxes. This offers fast entry to payroll information chances are you’ll must evaluate on-line stories with out these columns taking an excessive amount of house on the report. With QuickBooks, you don’t get comparable customization choices.
Be taught extra about OnPay
Sq. Payroll: Finest for contractor funds
Sq. Payroll is an effective choice in case you’re searching for a QuickBooks Payroll different with an inexpensive contractor-only plan. It might not be as cost-efficient as its competitor, however it’s the most affordable on my listing for a month-to-month price of solely $6 per employee. It contains the whole lot it is advisable run payroll whereas staying authorized and compliant, like no-fee tax type processing on your 1099s. And given the worth, Sq. Payroll provides you loads of worth ― particularly in order for you an intuitive pay processing platform for you and your contractors.
Nonetheless, it lacks the great HR options and worldwide cost instruments that comparable payroll suppliers supply. It’s additionally greatest used with different Sq. merchandise, like Sq. POS. This lets you maximize its cost functionalities whereas leveraging the direct integration between its payroll and level of sale (POS) methods for straightforward knowledge transfers and worker tip or fee processing.
Pricing
With Sq. Payroll, you get two choices:
- Full-service payroll: $35 base price monthly plus $6 per worker monthly.
- Contractor-only payroll: $6 per employee monthly.
In comparison with the entire suppliers on my listing, Sq. Payroll gives probably the most inexpensive full-service payroll and contractor-only payroll plans. It can save you extra with this QuickBooks Payroll different, supplied you solely want primary HR instruments, equivalent to easy new rent onboarding, scheduling, and time monitoring options.
Sq. Payroll professionals and cons
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
When to decide on Sq. Payroll over QuickBooks Payroll
When you have a restaurant or retail store, utilizing Sq.’s merchandise can simplify your cost processes and operations. For instance, you should use Sq. On-line to handle your on-line retailer and after getting a bodily retailer, get Sq. POS to just accept funds and Sq. Payroll to course of workers payouts. Its advertising merchandise additionally show you how to construct shopper relationships by e-mail and textual content advertising campaigns. Whereas QuickBooks could have a number of merchandise, these are centered on cost and accounting options.
In contrast to QuickBooks Payroll, which doesn’t have a downloadable app, Sq. Payroll has separate apps for workers and employers. The app for workers capabilities as a self-service instrument the place your workers can entry payslips and tax varieties, verify schedules, get real-time messages, and clock in/out for work. In the meantime, the app for employers permits you to import timecards, ship funds, and handle payroll.
By way of contractor payouts, you can even use the Sq. Payroll app to course of funds for contract staff. You possibly can even pay them by guide verify, direct deposit, or by way of the Sq. Money App. With the QuickBooks contractor funds plan, your cost choice is barely by direct deposits, which could be limiting, particularly if in case you have staff preferring to obtain their pay by way of paychecks.
Be taught extra about Sq. Payroll
Paychex Flex: Finest for devoted payroll assist
Paychex gives a variety of HR and pay processing merchandise for companies of all sizes. Its core payroll software program is Paychex Flex, and relying on the plan chosen, you additionally get primary to superior HR instruments. Paychex even gives a studying administration system (LMS) that you would be able to add to its payroll platform for a price. That is nice for conserving staff engaged whereas rising their abilities.
It additionally offers entry to devoted payroll specialists who can reply your payroll-related questions and help with payroll runs. This units Paychex Flex other than QuickBooks Payroll and the others on my listing. With a devoted specialist who is aware of your distinctive payroll and enterprise wants, it can save you time explaining your state of affairs and get solutions shortly. Your devoted specialist also can uncover pay and tax points you’ll have missed.
Pricing
What I don’t like about Paychex is its non-transparent pricing. It’s important to name its gross sales crew to request a quote. And in case you’re getting different instruments, like its time-tracking module, it is advisable contact a separate crew to get pricing particulars. That is not like QuickBooks Payroll, Gusto, and Sq. Payroll, which all listing month-to-month charges on their web sites.
Paychex additionally gives completely different custom-priced packages relying on the scale of your online business. It has a solopreneur tier and plans for corporations with 50 to greater than 1,000 staff. For small companies with as much as 49 staff, it has three packages:
- Choose: Customized pricing
- Professional: Customized pricing
- Enterprise: Customized pricing
Whereas every plan contains its personal set of options, lower-tier plans supply the choice to buy additional instruments, equivalent to expense administration by way of Expense Wire, pre-employment screenings, recruiting and onboarding, and garnishment funds — a service that Gusto gives at no additional value. Even on the highest-tier plan, some instruments, equivalent to worker advantages, time and attendance, studying administration, and HR analytics, can be found solely as paid add-ons.
Paychex Flex professionals and cons
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
When to decide on Paychex Flex over QuickBooks Payroll
Paychex Flex gives extra payroll assist instruments than QuickBooks and different opponents. Along with its devoted payroll specialist, its Paychex Pre-check characteristic lets your staff evaluate their paychecks earlier than the scheduled pay day. This enables them to lift questions on lacking pay gadgets like additional time and, concurrently, allows you to reduce cost errors and keep away from pricey payroll errors.
Like Sq. Payroll, Paychex Flex can be an excellent choice for processing payroll whereas on the go. You can begin pay runs by way of its cellular app and proceed the place you left off in your laptop computer or desktop and vice versa.
And in case you’re searching for a monetary wellness program, Paychex gives monetary training programs and short-term loans on your staff. It even has an intuitive revenue calculator that lets your staff decide if their retirement plan is on monitor to fulfill their retirement objectives based mostly on the data that they supply. Not one of the suppliers on my listing, together with QuickBooks Payroll, have an analogous retirement readiness calculator.
Be taught extra about Paychex Flex
RUN Powered by ADP: Finest for scalability
In the event you fear your online business will outgrow QuickBooks Payroll, contemplate RUN Powered by ADP or ADP RUN instead. It gives the full-service payroll, tax submitting companies, and compliance assist that most of the greatest payroll software program bundle into their plans. ADP additionally has a wide range of HR services that may meet the wants of small to giant companies, making it extremely scalable in comparison with QuickBooks and the opposite QuickBooks Payroll alternate options on my listing (besides Paychex Flex).
If you need a small enterprise payroll system with nominal HR options, you can begin with ADP RUN. Its primary plan gives a greater vary of HR instruments than Paychex Flex and QuickBooks Payroll. If you need extra options or have an even bigger workforce, you’ll be able to swap to different merchandise like ADP Workforce, which is perfect for midsized to giant companies. You can even get ADP TotalSource, a skilled employer group (PEO) service that handles your day-to-day HR and payroll duties.
Pricing
ADP RUN is one other QuickBooks Payroll different that doesn’t listing its pricing on its web site. You may get a quote by contacting its gross sales crew.
It has 4 plans:
- Important: Customized pricing
- Enhanced: Customized pricing
- Full: Customized pricing
- HR Professional: Customized pricing
Whereas lots of its HR options, equivalent to studying administration and applicant monitoring, are solely out there in increased tiers, ADP RUN is best than Paychex Flex as a result of it solely fees additional for a handful of instruments, equivalent to time monitoring, retirement and medical health insurance plans, and staff’ compensation. Plus, with Paychex Flex, hiring and worker onboarding options are paid add-ons, even in case you get a better plan.
RUN Powered by ADP professionals and cons
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
When to decide on RUN Powered by ADP over QuickBooks Payroll
In the event you want a variety of HR options, higher-tier ADP RUN plans include strong recruitment instruments, equivalent to ZipRecruiter job postings, applicant monitoring, and background checks. You even get wage benchmark data that will help you appeal to certified candidates and gauge the competitiveness of your compensation bundle.
Along with its LMS, which helps you to assign and monitor the completion of on-line programs, it gives entry to a sexual harassment prevention coaching program that you would be able to readily deploy to staff. And that’s all on high of the in-app compliance alerts and HR assist you get from ADP’s crew of HR professionals who may help you navigate sophisticated HR points. You possibly can even entry advertising instruments and get authorized help by way of Upnetic’s advisors and authorized companies.
Additional, ADP RUN makes paying staff by way of paychecks simpler. It might put together the paychecks, stuff and seal them into envelopes, after which ship these to your workplace in time so that you can distribute to staff. It even gives verify signing companies and offers paychecks with 10 superior fraud safety options — a performance that QuickBooks and the others on my listing don’t present.
Be taught extra about RUN Powered by ADP
To see the way it compares with QuickBooks Payroll, learn our ADP vs QuickBooks Payroll article.
Do you have to select QuickBooks Payroll or another?
QuickBooks Payroll is a worthwhile funding for a lot of companies. Whereas it does value greater than opponents, QuickBooks gives an easy-to-learn payroll platform with all of the important HR instruments you want. In the event you already use the QuickBooks ecosystem, the marginally excessive value is price it for the convenience of use. Plus, the direct integration between QuickBooks merchandise minimizes the danger of getting knowledge errors as a result of it doesn’t require guide inputs.
Nonetheless, relying on the payroll software program options you’re searching for, chances are you’ll want to search out an alternative choice to QuickBooks Payroll. In the event you really need HR instruments, for example, different suppliers supply extra options and extra worth. Or, if it is advisable make funds to staff in different international locations, you’ll have to search out another, as QuickBooks doesn’t do international payroll.
QuickBooks Payroll different steadily requested questions (FAQs)
Which software program is greatest to make use of as a QuickBooks Payroll different?
Gusto, OnPay, and Sq. Payroll are three of my high alternate options to QuickBooks Payroll. Each Gusto and OnPay supply a feature-rich payroll platform with the core HR options it is advisable handle staff. Then again, Sq. Payroll has a contractor-only plan that’s almost as inexpensive as QuickBooks’ contractor funds bundle.
How ought to I swap from QuickBooks Payroll to a different supplier?
Altering software program suppliers entails conducting product analysis, evaluating the choices out there, and guaranteeing that the QuickBooks Payroll different you choose has the important thing options you want at a worth inside your funds. Subsequent, you arrange your account with the brand new supplier, add your knowledge into the brand new system, and carry out check payroll runs to ensure accuracy. Then, you create and implement a communication and coaching plan so your staff know what to anticipate and when their new consumer coaching periods will occur.
Which different to QuickBooks Payroll is probably the most cost-effective?
Based mostly on my listing of greatest QuickBooks Payroll alternate options, Sq. Payroll is probably the most cost-effective. It has probably the most inexpensive plans for operating worker payroll and processing contractor-only funds.
Methodology
Usually, I exploit a rubric and my knowledgeable evaluation to check software program choices. Nonetheless, for this text, I leveraged my decade-long experience in human sources and 6 years of expertise reviewing HR and payroll software program to find out the most effective alternate options to QuickBooks Payroll. I began my analysis by analyzing 9 in style payroll methods for small companies. These choices embody:
- Gusto
- SurePayroll
- Paychex Flex
- ADP RUN
- Rippling
- Patriot Payroll
- Wave Payroll
- OnPay
- Sq. Payroll
Then, I in contrast every software program supplier’s pricing, buyer assist choices, and common ease of use. I even checked consumer opinions on dependable on-line websites like G2 and Capterra. I additionally appeared for key payroll and HR options that QuickBooks Payroll lacks and areas the place its opponents excel. After an intensive evaluate, I narrowed my listing right down to the highest 5 choices, specializing in platforms which are typically straightforward to make use of, supply extra HR options, and are extra inexpensive than QuickBooks Payroll.
If you wish to study our ordinary analysis course of, try our payroll software program evaluate methodology web page.